Need Tally
for Clients?

Contact Us! Here

  Tally Auditor

License (Renewal)
  Tally Gold

License Renewal

  Tally Silver

License Renewal
  Tally Silver

New Licence
  Tally Gold

New Licence
 
Open DEMAT Account with in 24 Hrs and start investing now!
« Top Headlines »
Open DEMAT Account in 24 hrs
 March 31 deadline is getting near. How to save income tax with tax loss harvesting?
 45-day MSME payment rule: Impact and details of Section 43B(h) explained
 Small savings schemes that offer tax benefits of up to Rs 1.5 lakh under section 80C
 RE-OPENING OF CORRECTION WINDOW FOR MAY 2024 CA EXAMINATIONS
 Powerful Upgrades, Tally 12+1 months renewal Plan and Connected Services for your growing Business - March 2024
 How innovative solutions can help fix the Sec 43B conundrum for MSMEs
 Income Tax dept asks many individuals to explain high value transactions of FY20-21 as Updated ITR deadline nears
 Release Notes for TallyPrime and TallyPrime Edit Log Release 4.1 | What s New!
 Deadline to file updated ITR FY20-21 ends on March 31: Details on additional tax
 4 tax-planning mistakes to avoid this season
 ITR 2024: Here are 8 ways by which senior citizens can save on taxes this year

Foreign law firms get tax reprieve from Bombay HC
January, 03rd 2009

Foreign law firms have received a shot in the arm following a judgement from the Bombay High Court which clearly states that their income will be taxable in India only to the extent of their operations in India.

An early beneficiary of the judgement has been Clifford Chance, a UK-based legal firm which during 1996-97 was appointed as legal advisors for three projects in India Bhadravati power project, Vizag power project and Ravva oil and gas fields project.

In the subsequent financial year, it began work on the Vemagiri power project as well. Only the Bhadravati project had an Indian firm Ispat Industries which was the JV partner for construction of the power plant. The partners for the other projects were not resident in the country.

Clifford Chance was remunerated on an hourly rate basis with each of its partners and employees maintaining detailed time sheets. This was a record of the time spent on doing such work in India and outside it. The bills so raised were paid to Clifford Chance by the clients outside India. The law firm filed a return showing an income liable to Indian taxation of Rs 5.08 crore.

According to the Income-Tax Department, the entire fee received by Clifford Chance from its clients for the four projects was taxable in India. This was irrespective of the fact that such fee was received for services rendered by it outside. The determining factor has been the place where the legal firms services were utilised and not the place where the services were performed. As such, the taxable income calculated by the department was Rs 17.26 crore.

Clifford Chances contention was that under the provisions of the Income-Tax Act and the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and UK, only that portion of its income from the clients which was attributable to the services performed by it in India could be subjected to Indian taxation.

The Income-Tax Tribunal as well as the Appellate Authority ruled in favour of the department. This was on the grounds that even though services rendered by Clifford Chance outside India had to be excluded while computing tax, the advice given by the legal firm was for projects that were to be executed in the country.

Senior counsel Harish Salve argued before the Bombay High Court that the tax on professionals who have been in the country for over 90 days would be taxable under the Income-Tax Act. In order to be taxed here, the income must accrue or arise in India.

Applying this to a legal professional rendering advisory services, his presence at the time of rendering advice would be the basis for determining where income is taxable, he contended. He further submitted that the income of an individual from professional services, therefore, is taxable in the state of residence. It is additionally taxable in the other contracting state if the services are performed in that other state.

Home | About Us | Terms and Conditions | Contact Us
Copyright 2024 CAinINDIA All Right Reserved.
Designed and Developed by Ritz Consulting